Cardiology Business

Cardiac Tests & Procedures Cost Variability

A new JAMA study found substantial cost variations in common cardiovascular tests and procedures across top US hospitals. 

Boston-based researchers capitalized on the CMS Hospital Price Transparency rule (effective Jan 2021), which requires hospitals to publicly post projected out-of-pocket expenses, as well as payer-specific negotiated rates, for standard care services. 

The investigators gathered data from the 20 highest-ranking US hospitals (including Cleveland Clinic, Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, and Brigham and Women’s Hospital) and identified the following median payer-negotiated ranges across the hospitals:

  • Echocardiogram: $204 to $2,588
  • Stress test: $463 to $3,230
  • Right heart catheterization: $2,821 to $9,382
  • Coronary angiogram: $2,868 to $9,203
  • PCI: $657 to $25,521
  • Pacemaker implantation: $506 to $20,002

Costs varied widely even for the same procedure within a single hospital, depending on the payer. Here are the largest payer-specific interquartile ranges (the spread of the middle 50% of data) the researchers saw within the hospitals: 

  • Echocardiogram: $470 to $3,022 
  • Stress test: $776 to $3,473
  • RHC: $3,143 to $12,926 
  • Coronary angiogram: $4,011 to $14,486
  • PCI: $11,325 to $23,392
  • Pacemaker implantation: $8,474 to $22,694

The Takeaway

This study exposed huge hospital-level price variations for routine CV tests and procedures, which don’t seem to reflect differences in quality-of-care. The authors suggested that the variations “may instead reflect which stakeholder—hospital or insurance company—has stronger negotiating power in the boardroom, which is often dictated by market dynamics.”

Get the top cardiology stories right in your inbox

You're signed up!

It's great to have you as a reader. Check your inbox for a welcome email.

-- The Cardiac Wire Team